• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Goomba’s Pizzeria: Unleashing Delicious Italian Delights in Colmar

Goomba’s Pizzeria in Colmar, PA stands out for its authentic Italian flavors and generous portions. Known for their mouth-watering hoagies and heavenly pizza, this unassuming spot has garnered a loyal following. The DaFixer pizza, featuring sausage, broccoli rabe, roasted peppers, and garlic, is a standout choice. While some find the crust a bit dense, the flavorful sausage and generous toppings make up for it. For cheesesteak lovers, the Cooper with its perfect mix of beef, creamy cheese, and sweet onions is a must-try. Goomba’s is a paradise for food enthusiasts seeking indulgent, satisfying eats.

Goomba’s Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Jeff K.
Jeff K.

Best hoagie I've ever had Old Italian was delicious Will always stop when in the area

Andrea C.
Andrea C.

I'm originally from NY and have been in PA for 20 years. I always joked that I moved from the Hero sandwich district to the Hoagie sandwich district. Oh, how I missed a NY Godfather Hero. A colleague told me about Goomba's. OMG it's heaven. It is a very unassuming place. Actually, more of a small shop. No seating, no AC. Who cares... what you are bringing home makes anything worth it. I have heard that they make amazing pizza but every time I think about trying their pizza I go back to my Ole Italian. I recently had some friends out for a small reunion. I was asked if I would bring Goomba's. Everyone unanimously wanted the same thing! You can't drive north on 309 without stopping. Bring a cooler because guaranteed you will only be able to eat half!

Nicole P.
Nicole P.

Solid pizza and their chicken cheesesteak is yummilicious. The seeded roll seals the deal. They have self-serve pickles and peppers which is a nice touch and something you don't see everyday.

Minna H.
Minna H.

Overall, a solid pizza place that's a bit more elevated than your usual local shop. Highlights: - DaFixer pizza: a white pizza with sausage, broccoli rabe, roasted peppers and garlic. Crust is a tad floppy but likely due to the generous amount of toppings - cheese pizza with sausage: their sausage flavor is solid, real flavorful sausage, not the cheap stuff Less enthused: - their pizza crust: personally, it's a bit bready and dense for me. I prefer an airier crust

Josh S.
Josh S.

Goomba's is like a fat kids wonderland. Their cheesesteaks are definitely the best in the burbs but also rival the top (2) shops in South Philly. I always go Cooper with, it's a perfect combination of beef, salty creamy cheese, sweet onions and a great roll. But the food doesn't stop at the steaks. Great hoagies and pizzas. In fact they have pizzas that are 36"...that's right it's like eating a manhole cover. Absolute gluttony at it's finest. Add a side of scrapple fries and your doctor will hate you, your body will punish you but your taste buds will make it all feel like bliss. This is a cheesesteak that is worth traveling to. An hour or more and I promise it will be well worth it.

Location

Welcome to Goomba’s Pizzeria, a hidden gem located in Colmar, PA, where pizza lovers flock to indulge in mouthwatering Italian classics. This cozy pizzeria offers a variety of options, from their famous hoagies to their colossal 36 pizzas, making it a favorite among locals and out-of-towners alike.

The menu at Goomba’s Pizzeria boasts a range of options that will tantalize your taste buds. Highlights include their DaFixer pizza, a white pie topped with sausage, broccoli rabe, roasted peppers, and garlic, as well as their cheese pizza with flavorful sausage. While some may find the crust a bit bready and dense, the generous toppings more than make up for it.

Customers rave about the quality of the food at Goomba’s Pizzeria, with many declaring it as their go-to spot for authentic Italian fare. Whether you’re craving a cheesy slice of pizza or a hearty cheesesteak, Goomba’s has something for everyone. And don’t forget to grab some self-serve pickles and peppers to complement your meal.

If you’re looking for a casual yet classy dining experience with excellent service and a welcoming atmosphere, look no further than Goomba’s Pizzeria. With options for delivery, takeout, and catering, as well as ample parking and outdoor seating, this pizzeria has everything you need for a memorable dining experience. So why wait? Make a reservation, grab a slice of heaven, and see for yourself why Goomba’s Pizzeria has become a local favorite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards